Example Grading Results

This is a sample grading result based on an M&A case study submission. See how MarkInMinutes provides detailed, actionable feedback.

Sample Assignment

M&A Case Study: Project Skadi

Anonymous 12/19/2025

94%

Passed

ECTS: A • Mark: 1.0

Submitted Files

groups1_44968_1383674_Company Project_Group 1_Project Skadi_Letter to the IC.pdf

APPLICATION/PDF

groups1_44968_1383682_Company Project_Group 1_Project Skadi_IC Presentation.pdf

APPLICATION/PDF

Processing Time:154.0s
Tokens: 168.106 (163.359 in, 4.747 out)Cost: $0.3837gemini-3-pro-preview
Executive Summary

Strengths

  • Sophisticated Strategic Framework Application
  • Rigorous Value Driver Decomposition
  • Precision in meeting constraints
  • Actionable Integration Strategy
  • Masterful use of the 'Pyramid Principle' in structuring the argument.

Areas for Improvement

  • Minor Inconsistency in Data Rigor
  • Digitalization Impact Quantification
  • Fragmented Risk & Mitigation presentation
  • Lack of explicit 'Next Steps' in the Letter
  • Minor clarity issue in the cover letter's listing of targets.

Recommendation

Overall score: 93.8% (A)

Dimension Scores

The submission demonstrates exceptional conceptual depth, particularly in its strategic framing of the M&A approach and value creation drivers. The group moves beyond standard reporting to apply sophisticated frameworks (e.g., 'Strategic Umbrella' integration, detailed Value Creation Bridge) that reveal a deep understanding of the private equity thesis.

The submission is an exemplary response to the RFP, demonstrating professional-grade adherence to all constraints and deliverables. The proposed buy-and-build strategy is highly actionable, with a well-selected nucleus (WAGNER) and a logically coherent add-on roadmap that fits the specific financial and strategic criteria provided. The inclusion of comprehensive valuation analysis, scenario planning, and a specific integration strategy ('Strategic Umbrella') elevates the solution from a classroom exercise to a realistic investment proposal.

The submission demonstrates an exemplary command of rhetorical structure and narrative flow, effectively utilizing the Pyramid Principle to present a compelling investment case. The 'Red Thread' is maintained flawlessly from the executive summary through to the conclusion, with sophisticated conceptual frameworks (e.g., the 'Strategic Umbrella' model) that synthesize complex strategic decisions into a clear, persuasive story.

The submission demonstrates an exceptional level of visual polish, effectively indistinguishable from professional materials produced by top-tier strategy consulting or private equity firms. The group utilizes a sophisticated design language with consistent color palettes, precise alignment, and high-value data visualizations—such as bridge charts and strategic frameworks—that actively advance the investment narrative. The layout hierarchy is masterful, using action titles and structured grids to make complex financial and strategic data easily digestible.

Graded by: ai (gemini-3-pro-preview)

Graded: 19.12.2025, 22:48:13

Ready to grade your own submissions?

Experience AI-powered grading that saves you hours while delivering consistent, detailed feedback.